The Lean Energy Management Technique

Dear Energy Manager, 

If you were managing a young "startup" company you would be aware of "The "Lean Startup Movement" - a concept for refining objectives of small companies who are trying to "change the world" developed by a smart chap called Eric Ries.

The Lean Startup Process
As an energy manager (in fact this is true for many managers), you may notice three things:
  1. You are also someone trying to change something 
  2. Your job is never done - success is somewhere you pass through on the way up
  3. You need to be lean (because there is never much fat in the energy budget)
I have argued before this puts energy managers into a context that is rather like entrepreneurial development. 

By definition you will not succeed !

Written like this, it sounds like a thankless and futile life, but it is not. What matters is not only improvement and enhancement, but the management of things that slip backwards and elimination of things that do not work.

This tells us three things:

Firstly - You are like a startup founder

You are in the midst of a circular process, which we can look at in a minute, and trying to find better ways of solving existing energy related problems. (i.e. disruptive innovation).

You reject the "its always been done that way" argument - you seek change.

Secondly - Some things do go wrong, (that's a part of life), but the energy manger responds.
  • by learning fast (and wasting the minimum during the learning process) 
  • by changing direction towards achievable goals
And Third - Some initiatives work. 

There are things that might take off, could be rolled-out. but need a development process, budgets and a management process ( a business model). Inshort these incubated ideas need nurturing (very much as an investor backs a small startup which shows some chance of rewards).

How does this look like founding a business ?

A business that does not have enough cash goes out of business, and a small company starts with very little cash. An energy management project is the same (examine it, try it, see if it flies, if it does roll it out, but if it doesn't kill it fast and move the budgets to some possibly better alternative.

A business is like a series of experiments ("I think this will sell", "let's try offering this", "maybe people will come back if we").

These experiments succeed or fail. Like you the startup company has limited resources - if it is going to fail, you need to "fail fast", that is to say stop digging! In the startup world this is followed by a "pivot" - ie a change or improvement in direction.

The very same is true of an energy manager, you have limited social capital, credibility or funds, and when these dry up you are out of business (literally and perhaps in a very personal and painful way).

Why does intelligence matter ?

Measurement (against expected targets) is the only way of knowing if it is working. 

It amazes me when an energy manger is conned into buying some "snake-oil" product and rolls these out because the salesman "promised it worked". We have seen this in the biggest engineering companies of the world, in the smartest money hungry companies, and in highly respected research establishments. Honestly, when someone finds a way of getting more calories out of a drop of oil by waving magnets, crystals or pyramids over it, I will hang up my hat - Meanwhile the laws of Physics Rule!

So every experiment (or hypothesis) regards how you will save money should have some acid test. You need to know if it works (in hindsight - not whether you believed at the outset - we can all convince ourselves).

Need for decisiveness

Proverbs 26:11 tells us: "As a dog returneth to his vomit, so a fool returneth to his folly." (King James).
Whether you believe in something or not initially, if it does not work - don't do it. It is far easier to keep trying something that you once believed in. But that is foolish. So the best approach is to define your criteria for success up front. Then test, test, test. And if it works refine, refine, refine. And if it doesn't reject and move on.

Why does speed matter ?

Failing fast, is not only about noticing the sooner you stop digging the less it hurts. It is also about recognizing that you have a limited time (runway in startup parlance) before your money or resources run out, and you can only bankroll a limited number of experiments. Going to corporate finance with a plan is much easier if you stopped the financial haemorrhages that did not work, before the well ran dry.

More importantly failing fast is a mind set. If you get stuck in a rut, momentum builds up and its much harder to stop the runaway. So the key idea of fail-fast is to learn at the earliest possible opportunity, with least possible cost when to change track.

And back to the top...

For convenience I have repeated the chart here. 
If you click it gets bigger

The only significant difference is that bureaucrats in energy management and international standards ISO 50001 seem to like long words like "Implementation and Operation" or "internal Audit"  , but I think we get the picture :)
IS0 50001 process concept (links to kWIQly)

For me the most telling words are those in the middle of the lean-startup movement diagram.

So, respond powerfully, intelligently, and rapidly, you know why we are called kWIQly  - but these words could be the survival mantra of the energy manager

"Minimize the total time through the loop"

Related articles
Enhanced by Zemanta

Be a thought leader - Yawn

Can we change the world - How ?

Obviously the answer is yes - everything we do changes the world. But sometimes we forget and so overlook tiny opportunities. And tiny opportunities can really change the world. Naturally, it is really satisfying when we can be significant, or even measurable.

Some people are paid to change our behaviour - the list includes (for good or bad) schoolteachers, politicians, energy managers and naturally marketing people and company leaders.  And thought leadership is available for all...

Comfort, energy waste and the heating season

So another long balmy summer comes to a sudden end (or does it)?

No - Sharply defined heating seasons are a lazy shorthand for "I don't care if I maximize comfort given my energy budget".

How to be #1 as an energy manager

Some of you will have seen the spectacular new video advert for Guinness by their agency BBDO.

If you haven't please just watch this first - and enjoy being truly blown away!

And then maybe come back and find out what this has to do with energy management.

If you watched the video - you just saw something unapologetically value-laden, energetic, smart and you grasped the point in around 40 seconds - the rest after that was just pure warm fuzzy stuff.

And the pure warm fuzzy stuff was the whole point (Drinking Guinness with your mates) is about caring! - That is pretty astonishing stuff in the masculine world of the beer commercial.

Six poor ways of finding waste and "Why?"

Today a question about questions. Phrasing the key question to find energy waste is important.

A question can elicit an explanation if well-phrased but may waste time with meaningless data otherwise.

Know waste, No nonsense, Know Now !

There has been a lot of discussion recently about relative merits of "energy audits that involve site visits" versus so called "virtual energy audits".  A lot of this discussion has been a waste of breath, and some useful points have been overlooked that actually serve the energy manager contemplating one or the other (or both).

Clearly, as engineers and energy managers, we should be capable of assessing an issue with a degree of objectivity.

What promises do you keep ?

What promises do you make in your working life ? 

Do you start with Money, Carbon, Cost, Comfort or simply compliance?

Who do you make them to (senior management or all building users equally), compliance officers, human resources , the union etc etc?

 - and why should they believe you ? !

My friend +William Mougayar recently wrote a post Introducing Product-Value Alignment at Startup - it taught me a few things and I liked, for example, his definition of a value proposition : 

"the most convincing promise you make to your users, customers, and prospects."

Naturally this applies to energy managers although William writes for entrepreneurs and Venture Capitalists - How so? ... 

The reason is simple - any energy manager is driving change in an existing environment and must operate very much like the manager of a startup company. To achieve change disrupts, and disruption can be a great thing, but change is risky!

So energy managers can be thought of as (and to an extent should be treated like) entrepreneurs, where innovation involves both risk and good rewards for success

Many engineers during their childhood learned from a simple idea:
"If it can be fixed - break it !"

Matching energy demand and supply (compensation)

I  just added an brief entry to the kWIQly resources page which will help anyone wanting to understand the basics of how direct compensation can be implemented mathematically. Do feel free to use it in energy management or building services course materials etc.

However, more important for energy managers is knowing why and when to use compensation and more specifically its' superiot lesser known cousin, direct compensation.

The emphasis of this post is not about how it works, but why, the particular benefits and pit-falls, and how you can improve on it.
Direct compensation helps match supply of energy to demand
Compensation Is a key means to save energy

Definition of Temperature Compensation

Compensation is a strategy to save energy in buildings and is a principle strategy widely used to define target flow temperatures for most Variable Temperature Zones that may support Fan-Coils, VAV units radiators etc.